Friday, 22 October 1999 Washington, DC

1. POLYGRAPH: SENATE CALLS ON NIH TO EXAMINE POLYGRAPH VALIDITY.
A Sense of the Senate resolution attached to the Labor, HHS Appropriations Bill calls on NIH to investigate the validity of the polygraph as a screening tool. A 1983 study by the Office of Technology Assessment found little evidence to support such applications. A letter from Senator Jeff Bingaman (D-NM) to NIH Director Harold Varmus notes that polygraphy is based on theories of psychophysiological phenomena that are "within the technical expertise of the NIH." NIH is asked to initiate and support a study by the National Academy of Sciences updating the 1983 OTA study. Meanwhile, DOE Secretary Bill Richardson, feeling the heat from the labs, has scaled back the testing plan from some 5,000 weapons scientists to about 1,000 people in sensitive jobs. However, if the polygraph doesn't work, no one should be tested.

2. BUDGET: PRESIDENT SIGNS THE VA/HUD/IA APPROPRIATIONS BILL.
The final deal negotiated on a bipartisan basis between the White House and Congress, restored the science cuts made by the House (WN 10 Sep 99). The NASA budget is actually increased $100M over the request after being cut $1B by the House. NSF is up 6.5% over last year, mostly for Information Technology and biocomplexity.

3. MIR: RUSSIA WANTS SHUTTLE TO RETRIEVE "VALUABLE" EQUIPMENT.
The 11.5 tons (yes, NASA used "tons") of stuff, valued at about a billion dollars by the Russians, would be used on the Russian ISS modules. Does it seem likely that the US would agree to send a shuttle to pick up outdated equipment that cost about as much as a shuttle flight? Meanwhile, a group of US entrepreneurs proposes to use a 7 kilometer electrodynamic tether to save Mir, though it's not clear where the electric power would come from. In the past, attempts to deploy tethered satellites have been a source of embarrassment for NASA (WN 11 Mar 94) and (WN 1 Mar 96).

4. CELLULAR PHONES: 20/20 REVIVES THE BRAIN CANCER CONTROVERSY.
It began in 1993 when a Florida man brought suit against cellular phone companies after his wife died of brain cancer. "She talked on the thing all the time and held it against her head," he said on Larry King Live (WN 29 Jan 93). That was the extent of the evidence and a federal judge threw out the claim two years later (WN 26 May 95). Wednesday night, ABC News 20/20, in what Diane Sawyer called "the report everyone will be talking about," asked its own experts. They were familiar to anyone who followed the power-line controversy. The editor of Microwave News, Louis Slesin, was repeatedly referred to as "Dr. Slesin." Doctor of what? Reached by phone this morning, he would not say. However, WN has confirmed that Slesin's PhD is in "Urban Studies and Planning." We don't know if "everyone is talking about" the 20/20 report, but Nokia, a major cell phone maker mentioned on the program, went up 8 points on the NY Stock Exchange.



Bob Park can be reached via email at whatsnew@bobpark.org
THE UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
Opinions are the author's and are not necessarily shared by the University, but they should be.