Friday, 19 March 93 Washington, DC

1. IT MAY BE DIFFICULT TO SEE CLEARLY FROM INSIDE THE PORK BARREL
A letter arrived this week from the director of a project WHAT'S NEW had cited as a particularly dumb example of "academic pork." The writer accused WN of inconsistency for not identifying the Supercollider as an example of "Presidential pork barrelling." His confusion is profound, but not unique--Newsweek called the SSC a "quark barrel" project. You don't have to like the SSC to understand that it's not pork. Academic pork barrelling refers to the practice of earmarking funds for projects that have not had the benefit of impartial merit review. Never before has a science project been so reviewed as the SSC. In addition to the usual DOE advisory panels, DOE convened the Drell panel in 1990, followed by the Sculli report the same year and the Townes Task Force a year later. Nobody can count the Congressional hearings that have been devoted to the SSC; it has been debated for hours in Committee and on the floor of the House and Senate; every wart has been exposed in public--and it faces this gauntlet again each year. By contrast, nearly a billion dollars a year are spent on academic research projects that NO ONE has ever reviewed.

2. NO INCREASE IN BRAIN CANCER DETECTED AMONG ELECTRICAL WORKERS!
Reports of an association between "electrical occupations" and an increased risk of brain cancer and leukemia have been cited as evidence that 60Hz magnetic fields can induce cancer. Above- normal exposures to fields was inferred from job titles on death certificates, such as "electrician." But in a new study of 36,000 electric utility workers at Southern California Edison, research- ers sought to refine the occupational link by actually measuring the exposure of workers in different jobs. Improved assessment of exposure should give a stronger association--if exposure is a risk factor. To the surprise of the researchers, the association went away. Will this end the debate? Of course not. Critics argue that power company scientists were involved in the study.

3. GOLDIN IS GIVEN AUTHORITY TO REORGANIZE AND MAKE APPOINTMENTS
at NASA. With Sally Ride remaining obdurate in her refusal to take the job of NASA Administrator, the White House has liberated Bush appointee Daniel Goldin to go forward with the space station redesign and make organizational changes as well. Last week he announced creation of a new Office of Space Sciences, headed by Wesley Huntress; it will include Solar System Exploration, Space Physics and Astrophysics. Microgravity Material Sciences will be under a new Office of Life and Material Sciences. Meanwhile, Rep. George Brown (D-CA) is urging Goldin to salvage as much as possible of the existing space station design. Brown's concern is our international partners, but the European Space Agency has just announced a 5% cut of its own in the Columbus space module.



Bob Park can be reached via email at whatsnew@bobpark.org
THE UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
Opinions are the author's and are not necessarily shared by the University, but they should be.