Friday, April 1, 2011

1. APRIL FOOLS: A DAY LIKE ALL DAYS; TRUTH MUST BE SEPARATED FROM FRAUD.

I have no stomach for jokes today. The truth is too sad, and the lies too numerous.

2. FUKUSHIMA: HYDROGEN EXPLOSION IN THE REACTOR #4 SPENT-FUEL POOL.

It may be months before events at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant are sorted out following the massive earthquake on 11 Mar 2011 at 14:46 JST and the huge tsunami it caused. The major concern involves the fuel storage pool for reactor #4 which held the entire complement of fuel rods from the reactor coreand may yet melt down. The rods had been removed just three months earlier. Reactors 4, 5 and 6 had been shut down prior to the earthquake for scheduled maintenance. The remaining reactors shut down automatically during the earthquake, but the 14 meter tsunami flooded the plant, knocking out emergency generators needed to run the pumps that cool and control the reactors; damage to transportation blocked help from elsewhere. It gets worse. Four days later, 15 March at about 06:00 JST, a hydrogen bubble that had collected above the spent fuel pond exploded, heavily damaging the rooftop area of the Unit 4 reactor. At 09:40, the Unit 4 spent-fuel pool caught fire. It was extinguished by 12:00, but not before huge amounts of radioactive contaminants had been released. That should not have happened. A hydrogen bubble is explosive only when mixed with a critical level of oxygen. During the 1979 Three-Mile Island accident, it was feared that a large hydrogen bubble in the containment dome would explode rupturing the building. It did not happen, but I have repeatedly urged that a tuft of "platinum wool" always be attached at the high points of nuclear containment buildings where hydrogen bubbles would be expected to collect. The platinum would catalyze the oxidation of hydrogen back to water before the mixture reaches an explosive level. The one-time cost would be trivial.

2. GROWTH: 2011 CENSUS PUTS THE POPULATION OF INDIA AT 1.21 BILLION.

Most of India's newborns are male according to the new 2011 census. The Census is taken every 10 years. For every 1000 boys born, 917 girls were born. The imbalance is greater than in 2001. It does not reflect some biological advantage of Y chromosomes; rather daughters in India tend to be regarded as financial burdens. Female feticide remains common in India, even though sex-selective abortion based on ultrasound scans is illegal. China remains the most populous sovereign nation at 1.3 billion, but India is closing fast at 1.21 billion, and now makes up 17% of the world population. India's fertility rate (2.68) is higher than it should be for sustainability (generally taken as 2.1), but only slightly above the world average for sovereign states (2.56). For comparison, the fertility rate in the US is given as 2.06. It should be recognized that a sustainable population does not mean a sustainable environment. Global warming, ocean garbage patches in gyres, shortages of fresh water and phosphates, accumulations of mine tailings and fly ash from coal-fired power plants, the Hubbert peak in oil, extinction of ocean fisheries and the apparent onset of the sixth great extinction, demonstrate that we have already far exceeded the sustainability limit. I would guess that the sustainability limit of high-technology society is not much over 1 billion. We need to have a discussion of what an appropriate limit would be.

Bob Park can be reached via email at whatsnew@bobpark.org
THE UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
Opinions are the author's and are not necessarily shared by the University, but they should be.