Friday, October 24, 2008

1. SCIENCE ADVICE: ADVISING THE PRESIDENT ABOUT ADVISORS.

Science magazine today has a brief assessment of where the candidates stand on ten science policy issues ranging from national security to space. Obviously staff written, it wasn't much help. We need to know to whom the future President will turn for advice on science-related matters. Presidents can call on anyone: FDR relied on Vannevar Bush, Truman on Isadore Rabi, Eisenhower to Killian and Kistiakowski, and Kennedy to Wiesner, none of whom are any longer available. Alas, the stature of the science advisor diminished seriously under Nixon and Reagan. It may have hit bottom in the 2003 state-of-the-union address when Bush announced his hydrogen initiative; it was clear that he had not bothered to check with his science advisor. The job is no longer seen as the "nation's top scientist." Whatever influence the science community has should be used to persuade the next President to select a wise science advisor as quickly as possible and rely on the science advisor's counsel.

2. OBAMA: ENDORSED IN LENGTHY NEW YORK TIMES EDITORIAL.

The Times, read daily by millions outside New York, today put its influence behind Barack Obama. Describing John McCain as "mired in the past," it was his choice of a running mate "so evidently unfit for the office," that was the decisive act of bad judgment. For what it's worth, What's New joins the New York Times in endorsing Obama, but you already guessed that.

3. PLACEBOS: STUDY FINDS DOCTORS OFTEN GIVE PLACEBOS.

I was shocked to read this in the New York Times this morning; shocked! Does this mean that all those antibiotic shots for colds, at 40 bucks a pop, were just a trick? Yes, but what a wonderful trick; you probably felt better before you left the doctor's office. And it's not just antibiotics for virus infections; it's Echinacea, and acupuncture, and homeopathy and herbal medicines, and spinal manipulation, and even a few surgeries. Pain is a message that something's broken; the placebo is a reply that it's being fixed. In Snake Oil Science, Barker Bausell explains that the brain responds to the placebo by releasing endorphins, endogenous opioids that block the pain receptors.

4. LHC: EARTH'S TOP PARTICLE ACCELERATOR DELAYED.

Officials at CERN say the Large Hadron Collider will be sidelined until late May or early June 2009. The time is needed for overhaul of a sector of the 27k machine to repair damage incurred on 19 Sept 08 when an electrical failure caused 6 tons of liquid helium to be dumped into the tunnel; 29 of the 10,000 magnets will need to be replaced.

5. CHANDRAYAAN-1: INDIA LAUNCHES SPACECRAFT TO MOON.

The Washington Post today reported that the launch confirms India's place as an emerging power in the new Asian space race. Astrologers among the astronomers in the Indian Space Research Organization declared 22 Oct 08 to be an auspicious day for the launch - not unlike American astronauts crossing themselves or saying a prayer before launch.

Bob Park can be reached via email at whatsnew@bobpark.org
THE UNIVERSITY OF MARYLAND
Opinions are the author's and are not necessarily shared by the University, but they should be.